Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach’s Christmas Oratorio

500px BWV 248 Autograph - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Leeds Minster

Saturday 22 November 7.30pm

Note: This is an annotated form of the programme notes for this recital, exploiting web technologies to allow readers to delve deeper into the biographies of the composers and the meaning of musical and religious terms as they wish.


Weihnachtsoratorium

(Christmas Oratorio)

BWV 248

Cantatas I-III

Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750)

Robert Ulrich tenor, Evangelist

Vocal soloists from St Peter’s Singers

18th Century Sinfonia

David Lewis leader

St Peter’s Singers

Alexander Woodrow conductor

We would like to thank Canon Paul Maybury, Rector, and the Churchwardens of Leeds Minster for their support for St Peter’s Singers


Welcome

Welcome to St Peter’s Singers’ performance of the first three parts of Bach’s Christmas Oratorio, performed with the 18th Century Sinfonia on period instruments. Leeds Minster provides a beautiful setting for this music, and we are delighted to share it with you this evening.

These first three parts tell the story of the Nativity: the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem, the angels’ announcement to the shepherds, and the shepherds’ journey to adore the newborn. The music is sung in German, and an English translation is provided to help you follow the story if you wish.

We invite you to listen in the way that feels most engaging — whether following the text, observing the performers, or simply letting the music fill the space around you.


Some practical information

There will be an interval after Cantata II, during which wine and juice will be available in the Lady Chapel. This can be reached by heading towards the altar, turning left at the steps, and going through the door.

We hope very much that you enjoy the music you hear today. If you do, and you wish to applaud, that will be very welcome just before the interval, and at the end.

Toilets can be found in the cafe, which is the room immediately on your right as you entered the church. You can reach it from the porch or from the back right corner of the main part of the church.

We welcome any comments or feedback you may wish to make after the concert. Please use our contact form.

Please note that audio and video recording of this concert is not permitted.


Programme

Weihnachtsoratorium

Cantata I

1Chorus: Jauchzet, frohlocket
2Recitative Evangelist: Es begab sich zu der Zeit
3Recitative Alto: Nun wird mein liebster Bräutigam
4Aria Alto: Bereite dich Zion
5Chorale: Wie soll ich dich empfangen
6Recitative Evangelist: Und sie gebar ihren ersten Sohn
7Chorale and Recitative Bass: Er ist auf Erden kommen arm
8Aria Bass: Grosser Herr, O starker König
9Chorale: Ach mein herzliebes Jesulein

Joanna Gamble alto
Richard Pascoe bass

Cantata II

10Sinfonia
11Recitative Evangelist: Und es waren Hirten in derselben Gegend
12Chorale: Brich an, O schönes Morgenlicht
13Recitative Evangelist: Und der Engel sprach zu ihnen
14Recitative Bass: Was Gott dem Abraham verheissen
15Aria Tenor: Frohe Hirten, eilt
16Recitative Evangelist: Und das habt zum Zeichen
17Chorale: Schaut hin, dort liegt im finstern Stall
18Recitative Bass: So geht denn hin, ihr Hirten, geht
19Aria Alto: Schlafe, mein Liebster, geniesse der Ruh
20Recitative Evangelist: Und alsobald war da bei dem Engel
21Chorus: Ehre sei Gott in der Höhe
22Recitative Bass: So recht, ihr Engel, jauchzt und singet
23Wir singen dir in deinem Heer

Sarah Rushton soprano
Constanze Hartley alto
John Scholey tenor
Quentin Brown bass

Interval

Wine and Juice will be available in the Lady Chapel

Cantata III

24Chorus: Herrscher des Himmels, erhöre das Lallen
25Recitative Evangelist: Und da die Engel von ihnen gen Himmel fuhren
26Chorus: Lasset uns nun gehen gen Bethlehem
27Recitative Bass: Er hat sein Volk getröst
28Chorale: Dies hat er alles uns getan
29Aria Duet Soprano and Bass: Herr, dein Mitleid
30Recitative Evangelist: Und sie kamen eilend
31Aria Alto: Schliesse, mein Herze, dies selige Wunder
32Recitative Alto: Ja ja, mein Herz soll es bewahren
33Chorale: Ich will dich mit Fleiss bewahren
34Recitative Evangelist: Und die Hirten kehrten wieder um
35Chorale: Seid froh dieweil
35aChorus: Herrscher des Himmels, erhöre das Lallen

Debbie Trigg soprano
Lucy Appleyard alto
Quentin Brown bass


About the Christmas Oratorio

A performance of JS Bach’s Christmas Oratorio rarely fails to lift the spirits. The music is by turn festive, energised, reflective and tender, and Bach deploys it with great skill both to tell the story and to reflect on its meaning. Whether it be the expression of a parent’s wonder at their child’s birth, the exquisite harmonisation of simple hymn tunes, the adrenaline that laces some of the choruses, or the majestic thrill of the high trumpets, there is a wide range of emotions to be experienced and musical delights to be enjoyed.

It is not hard to see why this work enjoys a similar profile in the affections of German choirs and music lovers to that enjoyed by Handel’s Messiah in this country. Whether this is your first encounter with Bach or one of many, the music communicates clearly through energy, emotion, and narrative; we hope you enjoy the performance and experience the vivid storytelling, expressive music, and rich textures.

These first three parts set the scene for the Nativity, inviting listeners into a story told through both narrative and reflection. The music captures the wonder and intimacy of these events with clarity and emotional depth.

Composed in 1734 during Bach’s Leipzig years, the Christmas Oratorio demonstrates his skill at combining expressive vocal writing with imaginative orchestration. Bach reworked earlier music into these cantatas, re-shaping it to serve the sacred story with dramatic and emotional impact.

In Parts 1–3, you will hear:

  • Choruses: complex music sung by the whole choir representing the church or collective characters such as the shepherds
  • The Evangelist: a tenor soloist who tells the story
  • Vocal soloists reflecting on the story and expressing human interest
  • Trumpets and timpani, bringing brightness and celebration
  • Flutes and oboes, evoking pastoral scenes
  • Strings and continuo, providing warmth and continuity
  • Chorales, familiar hymn tunes harmonized with clarity and richness

History and Creation of the Christmas Oratorio

The Christmas Oratorio was first performed in the churches of St. Thomas and St. Nicholas in Leipzig, where Bach was Kantor, over the Christmas and New Year period of 1734–35. The performance was spread out over the six services prescribed by the Lutheran Church for the Feast Days of Christmas. It is structured as six cantatas, one for each service, and would have been performed as follows:

25 December: Cantata I – The Birth of Christ
26 December: Cantata II – The Angels tell the Shepherds about Christ’s birth
27 December: Cantata III – The Adoration of the Shepherds
1 January: Cantata IV – The Circumcision and Naming of Christ
5 January: Cantata V – The Journey of the Wise Men
6 January (Epiphany): Cantata VI – The Adoration of the Wise Men

Four of the six cantatas were performed twice on the appointed day, in what must have been an extraordinarily tiring period for both Bach and his performers. These days, the economics of music production ensure that this is never likely to be repeated!

But the work’s genesis is not all that it seems at first sight. First, it is not entirely clear why Bach wrote it, as he had already composed plenty of cantatas for the Christmas period that could have been performed; and second, Bach ‘recycled’ much of the music from other works (mostly secular cantatas), raising the question of what his creative intentions really were.

There are a number of indicators that Bach may have envisaged a future in which it would be performed as a single work in its entirety. In his autograph, the movements are numbered sequentially throughout the entire work (the numeration adopted in this programme). Moreover, the texts chosen for the cantatas do not faithfully match those prescribed for the services, but they do comprise the full Christmas narrative, ensuring there are no gaps in the story that would compromise a full performance. The year 1734 also saw the composition of the St. Mark Passion, the Ascension Oratorio, and the Easter Oratorio, so he may have had in mind the creation of a set of oratorios based on the life of Christ.

If performance as a single work was Bach’s intention, his success was only partial. After its first hearing in 1734, it did not receive another complete performance until 1857. At about three hours, a full performance makes considerable demands on both performers and audience, so performances are usually truncated, as tonight, to just three or possibly four of the cantatas, with both economics and logistics making it increasingly challenging to put on two concerts covering the entire work.

Bach and the Use of Parody

The Christmas Oratorio is notable for its use of a technique known as Parody, where existing music is repurposed for use in a different context. In its most basic form, Bach had been a parodist all his life, copying and then extending existing music as a way of learning—his reworking of Vivaldi’s violin concertos for keyboard being a good example.

Bach’s astonishing output in his first years after arriving in Leipzig in 1723—five annual cycles of weekly cantatas, plus the St. John and St. Matthew Passions—involved the composition of mostly new music. But from 1729, Bach shifted his creative focus from church to secular music, investing time in directing the student Collegium Musicum and in writing secular cantatas praising worldly princes, probably in the hope of gaining employment as a Court Composer. At the same time, he became a prolific and sophisticated parodist of his own music, particularly when producing music for the church.

Late in 1733 came the composition of two secular cantatas (BWV 213 and BWV214), from which he was to borrow extensively for the Christmas Oratorio. Of tonight’s music, no fewer than seven substantive numbers (Nos. 1, 4, 8, 15, 19, 24, 29) were parodies, drawn from these two cantatas. Secular cantatas were strictly one-offs written for specific occasions, and there is clearly a temptation, voiced by Alfred Dürr in his foreword to the Bärenreiter edition in use tonight, to think that even as Bach composed them, he may have been considering how he could transfer the music to a place in the Church’s calendar where it would be heard more often.

The question that may arise for some is whether secular and sacred music are not so intrinsically different as to make such repurposing impossible. For Bach, this issue clearly didn’t arise, but he was incredibly thoughtful about how he reused the music.

The text is clearly the major factor in determining whether a piece of music is secular or sacred, and there are signs that Bach may have planned very carefully with his (unknown) librettist which movements from the secular cantatas were to be used and how—necessary, of course, to allow the librettist to prepare new and suitable texts.

Given the right text, Bach could, with minimal changes, effect a complete transformation in how the music was played and heard. In his book Music in the Castle of Heaven, John Eliot Gardiner observes how, while retaining exactly the same notes but making just a few changes to their articulation and adding an oboe d’amore, Bach completely transforms Aria No. 4 from the “indignant mood of Hercules berating Lust” in BWV 213 to the Oratorio’s “tender, almost erotic exhortation to Zion to prepare herself for the coming of the Messiah”.

Bach’s choice of instrumentation also shows how carefully the Parody was planned. Take, for instance, the use of trumpets—an instrument associated at that time purely with regal affairs and kings. BWV 214 contained an aria featuring a spectacular trumpet obbligato that praised the Queen of Poland. Bach repurposed it as tonight’s Bass Aria No. 8 to drive home the theologically central message of the Christmas story: that the object of all the kingly pomp and splendour was, in fact, a lowly baby born in a manger. The reuse of trumpet music in Cantatas I and III is then offset by the reuse, in Cantata II, of music for the more pastoral flutes and oboes to portray the annunciation to the shepherds in their fields.

But well as the planning worked for the most part, there are also signs that Bach abandoned some of his plans when the intended Parody didn’t work: for instance, Mary’s intense reflection on the wonders surrounding her child’s birth (No. 31) was originally to have been a Parody, but in the end, Bach composed new music for it and used the intended music for a bass aria on a rather different theme in Cantata V instead.

Chorales

The Christmas Oratorio is notable in two ways for its chorales—the well-known hymns that appear at intervals throughout the work and, as with all Bach’s church cantatas, close each Cantata. The curiosity is that Bach never wrote an original hymn tune, preferring instead to harmonise well-known tunes (many composed by Martin Luther himself), presumably so that the congregation could join in the singing. The harmonisations in this work are particularly warm and also sophisticated in the way passing dissonances emerge from the intersection of the different voice parts.

The Christmas Oratorio is exceptional in that it provides the earliest known version of a number of hymn tunes. But Bach also uses Luther’s tune Vom Himmel hoch three times (Nos. 9, 17, 23), as well as the tune used repeatedly in both Passions and known as the Passion Chorale (No. 5). It may be of interest to some to note that in No. 9, the text is also Luther’s, and one that has found its way into the English-speaking world as a Scottish lullaby we now know as the carol Balulalow. (see the anglicised version in the translation below).


German text and English translation

1 Chorus
Jauchzet, frohlocket, auf, preiset die Tage,
rühmet, was heute der Höchste getan!
Lasset das Zagen, verbannet die Klage,
stimmet voll Jauchzen und Fröhlichkeit an!
Dienet dem Höchsten mit herrlichen Chören,
lasst uns den Namen des Herrschers verehren!

Shout for joy, exult, rise up, praise the day,
extol what the Highest has done today!
Stop being faint-hearted, banish lamentation,
strike up, full of rejoicing and exultation!

Serve the Highest with splendid choirs,
let us revere the name of the sovereign!
2 Recit Evangelist
Es begab sich aber zu der Zeit, dass ein Gebot von dem Kaiser Augusto ausging, dass alle Welt geschätzet würde. Und jedermann ging, dass er sich schätzen liesse, ein jeglicher in seine Stadt. Da machte sich auch auf Joseph aus Galiläa, aus der Stadt Nazareth, in das jüdische Land zur Stadt David, die da heisset Bethlehem; darum, dass er von dem Hause und Geschlechte David war: auf dass er sich schätzen liesse mit Maria, seinem vertrauten Weibe, die war schwanger. Und als sie daselbst waren, kam die Zeit, dass sie gebären sollte.

The time came when a decree went out from Caesar Augustus that an assessment should be made of the whole world. And everyone went to be assessed, each to his own city. Then Joseph went up out of Galilee, from the city of Nazareth, into the land of Judea, to the city of David which is called Bethlehem – for he was of the house and lineage of David – to be assessed with his betrothed Mary, who was pregnant. And while they were there, the time came for her to give birth.
3 Recit Alto
Nun wird mein liebster Bräutigam,
nun wird der Held aus Davids Stamm
zum Trost, zum Heil der Erden
einmal geboren werden.
Nun wird der Stern aus Jakob scheinen,
sein Strahl bricht schon hervor.
Auf, Zion, und verlasse nun das Weinen,
dein Wohl steigt hoch empor!

Now my dearest bridegroom,
now the strong man of David’s stock,
for the comfort and salvation of the earth,
shall at last be born.
Now the star out of Jacob shall shine,
its rays already break forth.
Rise up, Zion, and stop weeping now:
Your welfare climbs on high!
4 Aria Alto
Bereite dich, Zion, mit zärtlichen Trieben,
den Schönsten, den Liebsten bald bei dir zu sehn!
Deine Wangen müssen heut viel schöner prangen,
eile, den Bräutigam sehnlichst zu lieben!

Make ready, Zion, with tender desire
to see the fairest, the dearest with you soon!

Your cheeks must today look much lovelier,
hasten, to love the bridegroom most longingly!
5 Chorale
Wie soll ich dich empfangen
und wie begegn’ ich dir?
O aller Welt Verlangen,
o meiner Seelen Zier!
O Jesu, Jesu, setze
mir selbst die Fackel bei,
damit, was dich ergötze,
mir kund und wissend sei!

How should I receive you
and how encounter you?
O longing of all the world,
O ornament of my soul!
O Jesus, Jesus, place
your lamp by me yourself,
so that whatever delights you
may be known and understood by me!
6 Recit Evangelist
Und sie gebar ihren ersten Sohn und wickelte ihn in Windeln und legte ihn in eine Krippen, denn sie hatten sonst keinen Raum in der Herberge.

And she gave birth to her first son and wrapped him in swaddling-clothes and laid him in a manger, for otherwise they had no room in the lodgings.
7 Chorale with Recit
Soprano
Er ist auf Erden kommen arm,
dass er unser sich erbarm,
und in dem Himmel mache reich,
und seinen lieben Engeln gleich.
Kyrieleis!
Bass
Wer will die Liebe recht erhöhn,
die unser Heiland für uns hegt?
Ja, wer vermag es einzusehen,
wie ihn der Menschen Leid bewegt?
Des Höchsten Sohn kömmt in die Welt,
weil ihm ihr Heil so wohl gefällt, 
so will er selbst als Mensch geboren werden.


He has come on earth poor,
to be merciful to us,
and make us rich in heaven
and like his beloved angels.
Lord, have mercy!

Who would rightly extol the love
that our Saviour feels for us?

Indeed, who is able to appreciate
how man’s suffering moves him? 

The Highest’s Son comes into the world
because its salvation pleases him so well

that he himself would be born as man.
8 Aria Bass
Grosser Herr, O starker König,
liebster Heiland, O wie wenig
achtest du der Erden Pracht!
Der die ganze Welt erhält,
ihre Pracht und Zier erschaffen, 
muss in harten Krippen schlafen.

Great lord, O mighty king,
dearest Saviour, O how little
you respect earthly splendour!

He who preserves the whole world
and created its splendour and adornment
must sleep in a hard crib
.
9 Chorale
Ach mein herzliebes Jesulein
Mach dir ein rein sanft Bettelein
Zu ruhn in meines Herzens Schrein
Dass ich nimmer vergesse dein!

Ah my dear heart, young Jesus sweet
Prepare a cradle in thy spirit
And I shall rock thee in my heart
And nevermore from thee depart!
(anglicised 1st verse of carol Balulalow; see notes)
10 Sinfonia
11 Recit Evangelist
Und es waren Hirten in derselben Gegend, auf dem Felde bei den Hürden, die hüteten des Nachts ihre Herde. Und siehe, des Herren Engel trat zu ihnen, und die Klarheit des Herren leuchtet um sie, und sie furchten sich sehr.

And there were shepherds in the same region keeping watch in the fields over their flocks by night. And see, the Angel of the Lord came to them, and the glory of the Lord shone round about them, and they were sore afraid.
12 Chorale
Brich an, O schönes Morgenlicht,
und lass den Himmel tagen!
Du Hirtenvolk, erschrecke nicht,
weil dir die Engel sagen,
dass dieses schwache Knäbelein
soll unser Trost und Freude sein,
dazu den Satan zwingen
und letztlich Friede bringen!

Break forth, O beauteous morning light,
and let the heavens dawn!
You shepherd folk, do not fear,
for the angels tell you
that this weak little boy
shall be our comfort and joy,
overcome Satan,
and finally bring peace!
13 Recit
Evangelist: Und der Engel sprach zu ihnen:
Angel, soprano: Fürchtet euch nicht.
Siehe, ich verkündige euch grosse Freude, die allem Volke widerfahren wird. Denn euch ist heute der Heiland geboren, Welcher ist Christus, der Herr, in der Stadt David.

And the angel said to them:
Be not afraid!
For behold, I bring you joyful news, which shall be to all people.
For unto you is born today in the city of David a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord.
14 Recit Bass
Was Gott dem Abraham verheissen,
dass lässt er nun dem Hirten Chor erfüllt erweisen.
Ein Hirt hat alles das zuvor von Gott erfahren müssen.
Und nun muss auch ein Hirt die Tat,
was er damals versprochen hat,
zuerst erfüllet Wissen.

What God once promised to Abraham,
he now fulfils in the sight of a choir of shepherds.
 A shepherd once learnt all this from God,
and now a shepherd is the first to know
that what was promised then
has now been fulfilled.
15 Aria Tenor
Frohe Hirten, eilt, ach eilet,
eh ihr euch zu lang verweilet,
eilt, das holde Kind zu sehn;
Geht, die Freude heisst zu schön,
sucht die Anmut zu gewinnen, geht
und labet Herz und Sinnen.

Haste, joyful shepherds,
do not linger,
haste to see the sweet child;
Go, such joy awaits you,
seek for yourselves his grace,
refresh your heart and senses.
16 Recit Evangelist
Und das habt zum Zeichen: Ihr werdet finden das Kind in Windeln gewickelt und in einer Krippe liegen.

And this shall be a sign to you: you shall find the child wrapped in swaddling clothes and lying in a manger.
17 Chorale
Schaut hin, dort liegt im finstern Stall
Des Herrschaft gehet überall!
Da Speise vormals sucht ein Rind,
Da ruhet itzt der Jungfrau’n Kind.

See, in yon gloomy stable lies 
He who rules the earth and skies,
Where once the hungry oxen fed,
The virgin finds her child a bed.
18 Recit Bass
So geht denn hin, ihr Hirten, geht, dass ihr das Wunder seht,
Und findet ihr des Höchsten Sohn in einer harted Krippe liegen.
So singet ihm bei seiner Wiegen aus einem süssen Ton und mit gesamten Chor dies Lied zur Ruhe vor.

So go, shepherds, go there, to see this wonder,
And find the son of the Most High lying in a hard crib.

So stand beside his cradle, and in sweet tones and with the whole choir, sing him this soothing song.
19 Aria Alto
Schlafe, mein Liebster,
geniesse der Ruh,
wache nach diesem vor aller Gedeihen!
Labe die Brust,
empfinde die Lust,
wo wir unser Herz erfreuen!

Sleep, my most beloved,
enjoy your rest,
then awake, and in all things thrive!

Comfort the breast,
feel the pleasure
with which we gladden our hearts!
20 Recit Evangelist
Und alsobald war bei dem Engel die Menge der himmlischen Heerscharen, die lobten Gott und sprachen:

And suddenly there was with the Angel the multitude of the Heavenly Host, praising God and saying:
21 Chorus
Ehre sei Gott in der Höhe,
Und Friede auf Erden,
Und den Menschen ein Wohlgefallen

Glory to God in the highest,
And Peace on earth,
Goodwill to all people
22 Recit Bass
So recht, ihr Engel, jauchzt und singet,
Dass es uns heut so schön gelinget,
Auf denn! Wir stimmen mit euch ein,
uns kann es so wie euch erfreun.

Tis right, you Angels, rejoice and sing,
Today is born our Lord and King, 
Sing then, we all will raise our voice
And with the Angels all rejoice.
23 Chorale
Wir singen dir in deinem Heer
Aus aller Kraft Lob, Preis und Ehr
Dass du, O lang gewünschter Gast,
Dich nunmehr eingestellet hast.

In chorus now to thee we raise
With all our might our songs of praise
That you, O long-awaited guest
 Has come at last, beloved and blest.
24 Chorus
Herrscher des Himmels, erhöre das Lallen,
Lass dir die matten Gesänge gefallen,
Wenn dich dein Zion mit Psalmen erhört.
Höre der Herzen frohlockendes Preisen
Wenn wir dir itzo die Ehrfurcht erweisen,
Weil user Wohlfahrt befestiget steht.

Ruler of Heaven, give ear to our babbling,
Let our songs be pleasing to you 
When Zion praises you in Psalms. 
Hear the joyful praise of our rejoicing hearts
When we show how we revere you, 
Because our welfare is assured.
25 Recit Evangelist
Und da die Engel von ihnen gen Himmel fuhren, sprachen die Hirten untereinander:

And as the angels went from them into heaven, the shepherds said to each other:
26 Chorus
Lasset uns nun gehen gen Bethlehem und die Geschichte sehen, die da geschehen ist, die uns der Herr kundgetan hat.

Let us now go to Bethlehem and see the event that has happened there, which the Lord has made known to us.
27 Recit Bass
Er hat sein Volk getröst’,
er hat sein Israel erlöst,
die Hülf aus Zion hergesendet
und unser Leid geendet.
Seht, Hirten, dies hat er getan;
geht, dieses trefft ihr an!

He has comforted his people,
he has redeemed his Israel,
sent salvation out of Zion,
and ended our sorrow.
See, shepherds, this he has done;
go, this is what you shall find!
28 Chorale
Dies hat er alles uns getan,
sein groß Lieb zu zeigen an;
des freu sich alle Christenheit
und dank ihm des in Ewigkeit.
Kyrieleis!

All this he has done for us
to show his great love;
for which let all Christendom rejoice
and thank him in eternity.
Lord, have mercy!
29 Aria Soprano
and Bass
Herr, dein Mitleid, dein Erbarmen,
Tröstet uns und macht uns frei.
Deine holde Gunst und Liebe,
Deine wundersamen Triebe,
Machen deine Vatertreu wieder neu.


Lord, your mercy, your pity
Comforts us and sets us free.
Your gracious favour and love,
Your wondrous desires
Ever renew your fatherly faithfulness.
30 Recit Evangelist
Und sie kamen eilend und funden beide, Mariam und Joseph, dazu das Kind in der Krippe liegen. Da sie es aber gesehen hatten, breiteten sie das Wort aus, welches zu ihnen von diesem Kind gesaget war. Und alle, für die es kam, wunderten sich der Rede, die ihnen die Hirten gesaget hatten. Maria aber behielt alle diese Worte und bewegte sie in ihrem Herzen.

And they came in haste and found both Mary and Joseph, with the child lying in the crib. But when they had seen it, they spread abroad the words that were spoken to them of this child. And all those to whom it came wondered at the speech that the shepherds had delivered to them. But Mary kept all these words and set them astir in her heart.
31 Aria Alto
Schliesse, mein Herze, dies selige Wunder
fest in deinem Glauben ein!
Lasse dies Wunder, die göttlichen Werke,
immer zur Stärke
deines schwachen Glaubens sein!

Enclose, my heart, this blessed miracle
firmly within your faith!

Let this miracle, these divine deeds
ever serve to strengthen
your weak faith!
32 Recit Alto
Ja, ja, mein Herz soll es bewahren,
was es an dieser holden Zeit
zu seiner Seligkeit
für sicheren Beweis erfahren.

Yes, yes, my heart shall preserve
what at this propitious time,
for its salvation,
it has known as certain proof.
33 Chorale
Ich will dich mit Fleiß bewahren,
ich will dir
leben hier,
dir will ich abfahren,
mit dir will ich endlich schweben
voller Freud
ohne Zeit
dort im andern Leben.

I will diligently keep you in mind;
I will
live here for you,
to you will I depart,
with you will I finally hover,
full of joy,
beyond time,
there in the other life.
34 Recit  Evangelist
Und die Hirten kehrten um, preiseten und lobten Gott, um alles, das sie gesehen und gehörten hatten, wie denn zu ihnen gesaget war.

And the shepherds returned, praising and glorifying God for all that they had seen and heard, as had been told to them.
35 Chorale
Seid froh dieweil, seid froh dieweil,
Dass euer Heil ist hie ein Gott und auch ein Mensch geboren,
der, welcher ist der Herr und Christ in Davids Stadt
Aus vielen auserkoren.

Rejoice, rejoice
That your salvation has been born here as God and human,
He who is the Lord and Christ in David’s city
Chosen from many.
Repeat No 24

The above translation is derived mainly from the Bach Archiv, but also occasionally from Henry Drinker’s work in the Bärenreiter edition.

Tonight’s artists

Robert Ulrich cropped 1024x1024 - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Robert Ulrich tenor, Evangelist

Robert began singing aged nine with the Regensburger Domspatzen, a renowned cathedral choir of Regensburg, Germany. His musical journey led him to perform as a soloist and in a variety of ensembles, gracing stages across the world. After studying Music at the University of Hull, he has continued to sing with local choirs and has a particular passion for Early Music.

Debbie Trigg 1 cropped - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Debbie Trigg soprano

Debbie has been passionate about singing from an early age, studying at Huddersfield University, and at Birmingham Conservative of Music with Pamela Cooke. She sang in the National Youth Choir and broadcast frequently from Manchester with the BBC Northern Singers under Stephen Wilkinson on Radio 3 and with the Daily Service Singers on Radio 4. She sang for many years with Manchester Chamber Choir. Now, in addition to a busy teaching practice, she sings with Huddersfield Choral and St Peter’s Singers, where she enjoys the chance to sing solo.

Sarah Rushton cropped 1024x1024 - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Sarah Rushton soprano

Sarah started singing when studying music at Birmingham University.  She joined St Peter’s Singers when she moved to Leeds for her first job and has sung with them ever since.  She has had singing lessons with Kathryn Woodruff in the past.  She also plays viola with Leeds Symphony Orchestra.

joannashiels - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Joanna Gamble contralto

Joanna has performed or covered principal rôles with many of the major British opera companies  including Opera North, Scottish Opera, WNO and Grange Park Opera. She specialises in Wagner roles and Russian and Czech repertoire but later in life has also found a home in the contralto rôles of Gilbert and Sullivan. Oratorio engagements have included Dvořak Stabat MaterElijah in Wells Cathedral; Messiah in Truro Cathedral, Hereford Cathedral and in Leeds Town Hall with the orchestra of Opera North; Szymanowski Stabat Mater; St John Passion with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra/Dunedin Consort at the Queen’s Hall Edinburgh; and she has toured Europe and Japan with Collegium Vocale under Philippe Herreweghe.

connie 1024x1024 - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Constanze Hartley contralto

German born Constanze Hartley developed a passion for Renaissance and Baroque music and ensemble singing during her school years when she received classical vocal training, and toured nationally and internationally with the school’s multi award winning youth choir. From those beginnings, she has sung in several small chamber choirs and ensembles in Germany and the UK before joining St Peter’s Singers, and is now a sought after consort singer and regularly performs at Leeds Minster for services and concerts.

Lucy Appleyard square - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Lucy Appleyard mezzo

Lucy is from the North Yorkshire village of Great Ayton where she began her singing career as a treble in the Choir of Christ Church. She pursued her formal training at Leeds College of Music, earning a BPA (Hons) in 2001 and a Master of Music in 2006. Lucy has performed numerous operatic roles on the local and national stage. She has worked professionally for Scottish Opera and has been a familiar face at the International Gilbert & Sullivan Festival. She sings as a soloist for many choral societies in Yorkshire and beyond. Outside of her performing career, Lucy works as a primary school music teacher in Leeds. She enjoys fell walking with her husband and their daughters.

John Scholey cropped 1024x1024 - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

John Scholey tenor

Born in Leeds, John Scholey is currently studying at Leeds University for a BMus Music Performance degree. He sings in a large number of local choirs, including St Peter’s Singers and the Choir of Leeds Minster.

John is a Section Leader in both the National Youth Choir and National Youth Voices. Notable engagements with these choirs include a recent tour to South Africa, five BBC Proms, and the 2023 Royal Variety Performance, alongside collaborations with Nicholas Collon and the Aurora Orchestra, Sofi Jeannin and the BBC Singers, amongst others. Beyond NYC, John was recently invited to take part in a residential project with the Royal Academy of Music’s Chamber Choir, and appears as a choir member in Alan Bennett’s new film The Choral.

Richard Pascoe Headshot 2025 Small cropped - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Richard Pascoe bass

Richard studied opera singing with Llyndall Trotman.  Otherwise, Richard has always sung purely for the joy of it.

Richard has been performing in amateur shows in Leeds for 25 years.  Highlights include:  The Baker in Into The Woods, Old Deuteronomy in Cats, Figaro in The Marriage Of Figaro, Ping in Turandot, The Sergeant in Pirates Of Penzance and The Judge (twice) in Sweeney Todd.  He will play Mr Lindquist in A Little Night Music in York in February.  He joined St Peter’s Singers in 2001 and was instantly hooked into the new (to him) world of high calibre choral singing. Richard runs MakingPresentations.co.uk – training leaders around the world in advanced presentation skills.

Quentin Brown croppedjpg - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Quentin Brown bass

Quentin started his musical life as a chorister at Rochester Cathedral. He has sung with the BBC Northern Singers and Pro Cantione Antiqua, and has been a member of St Peter’s Singers for over 40 years.

As a soloist he has performed works by composers ranging from Bach and Handel to Mozart, Beethoven, Verdi, Brahms, Elgar and Vaughan Williams.

Forthcoming engagements include Bach’s St John Passion, Mozart’s Requiem, and Handel’s Messiah with Black Dyke Band in Beverley Minster.

St Peters Singers 47732 1024x1024 - Concert Programme Notes for JS Bach's Christmas Oratorio

Alexander Woodrow conductor

Born in York in 1986, Alexander read music as Organ Scholar at Magdalene College, Cambridge. He became Fellow of the Royal College of Organists at the age of 19, is a Fellow of Trinity College London and recipient of the Silver Medal of the Worshipful Company of Musicians.

Alex is a distinguished recitalist and has regularly broadcast on BBC Radio and Television. He has performed in many of the major churches and cathedrals of the UK including York Minster, King’s College, Cambridge, and Westminster Abbey. Alex has held positions at Guildford Cathedral, St Albans Cathedral and Hexham Abbey and Bradford Cathedral. In 2020 he took up his current appointment as Organist and Director of Music at Leeds Minster.

Programme Notes for My spirit sang all day (Rawdon)

Image advertising a choral concert called My spirit sang all day

Note: This is an annotated form of the programme notes for this recital, exploiting web technologies to allow readers to delve deeper into the biographies of the composers and the meaning of musical and religious terms as they wish.


My spirit sang all day

Choral songs of the world and the spirit

Programme

Please click on the composers’ names to find about more about them

Hymn to St PeterBenjamin Britten (1913-76)
Tu es PetrusPierluigi da Palestrina (1525-94)
Geistliches LiedJohannes Brahms (1833-97)
Wie lieblich sind deine WohnungenJohannes Brahms (1833-97)
Organ solo: Sonata No 3 in A 1st MovtFelix Mendelssohn (1809-47)
Ave MariaSimon Lindley (1948-2025)
Brides of ChristFiona Pacey and Hannah Stone
Ave maris stellaEdvard Grieg (1843-1907)

Interval

during which refreshments will be served

My spirit sang all dayGerald Finzi (1901-1956)
The Blue BirdCharles Villiers Stanford (1852-1924)
The Turtle DoveRalph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)
My love dwelt in a Northern LandEdward Elgar (1857-1934)
Lay a garlandRobert Pearsall (1795-1856)
Organ solo: The PrayerDavid Foster (arr Lee Ward)
The Sound of SilencePaul Simon (b 1941)
Medley from West Side StoryLeonard Bernstein (1918-1990)

St Peter’s Singers

Lee Ward organ

Alexander Woodrow conductor


Texts, translations and notes

We begin our programme appropriately with two wonderful works written for performance at Petertide. Both reference the text in St Matthew Ch 16:18-21, where Christ calls Peter his Rock, the foundation for his Church, and gives him the keys to the Kingdom of Heaven.

Hymn to St Peter | Benjamin Britten (1913-76)

Thou shalt make them Princes over all the earth,
They shall remember thy name, O Lord,
Instead of thy fathers, Sons are born to thee.
Therefore shall the people praise thee, Alleluia.
Tu es Petrus, et super hanc petram aedificabo ecclesiam meam
Thou art Peter, and on this Rock I will build my church

From the Gradual of the Feast of St Peter and St Paul

This organ-accompanied anthem dates from 1955. The musical material of the imposing and stately opening ‘Thou shalt make them princes’ is based upon plainsong. A complete contrast ensues with the lively and skittish setting, in compound 6/8 time, of ‘instead of thy fathers, sons are born to thee’, before a return to the original stately theme, this time with the addition of a soprano soloist who sings the Latin ‘Tu es Petrus’ phrases, while the choir sings the English translation very quietly in response.

Soprano soloist:

Tu es Petrus | Pierluigi da Palestrina (1525-94)

A masterful piece of Polyphony dating from the 16th century. It was written to be sung a cappella in six parts, with each of the six voices having beautiful interweaving lines, all working together to produce some splendid harmonies. Several times, Palestrina breaks this seamless interweaving to make way for a unified, almost fanfare-like setting of the words ‘claves regni’ (the keys to the kingdom). These words are always presented in a very powerful way to lend them great prominence and to draw our attention to them.

Tu es Petrus, et super hanc petram aedificabo ecclesiam meam,You are Peter, the Rock, and on this rock I will build my church,
Et portae inferi non praevalebunt adversus eam.And the powers of death shall not prevail against it.
Et tibi dabo claves regni caelorum.
And I shall give to you the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven.
Quodcumque ligaveris super terram erit ligatum et in Coelis,Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven,
Et quodcumque solveris super terra erit solutum et in coelis,And whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven
Et tibi dabo claves regni caelorum.
And I shall give to you the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven.

Text: Matthew 16: 18-21

Geistliches Lied (Sacred song) | Johannes Brahms (1833-97)

Two choral works by Brahms allow the choir to revel in warm, blended tone and luxurious Romantic lines. Geistliches Lied was written in 1856 and has its origins as a contrapuntal exercise based  upon a double Canon, the tenor answering the soprano a bar later and a ninth lower; and the bass answering the alto also a ninth lower. That the piece is a hallmark not only of technical skill but of great overall elegance in the choral lines; the organ accompaniment is an exceptional achievement, and the final Amens are sumptuously beautiful.

 Lass dich nur nichts nicht dauren
mit Trauren
sei stille!
Wie Gott es fügt,
so sei vergnügt
mein Wille
 Let nothing afflict you
With grief;
Be calm!
As God ordains,
So be content
my Will
Was willst du heute sorgen
Auf Morgen?
Der Eine
Steht allem für,
Der gibt auch dir
Das Deine
Why worry today
About tomorrow?
The One
Is in charge
Who gives also to you
What is yours
Sei nur in allem Handel
Ohn Wandel,
Steh feste!
Was Gott beschleusst
Das ist und heisst
Das Beste, Amen
In all your doings
be steadfast
Stand firm!
What God decrees
Is, and is acknowledged
The best, Amen

Text: Paul Flemming (1608-40)

Wie lieblich sind deine Wohnungen | Johannes Brahms (1833-97)

This is the fourth movement of Brahms’ German Requiem, setting text from Psalm 84, and it is by some margin the best-known stand-alone movement from that wonderful work, with its soaring melodies and elegant phrases, its refined triple-time flow, and the exciting fugato passage ‘die Loben dich immerdar’ which eventually yields to a peaceful ending.

Wie lieblich sind deine Wohnungen, Herr ZebaothHow lovely are thy dwellings fair, O Lord of Hosts
Meine Seele verlanget and sehnet sich nach den Vorhöfen des HerrnMy soul hath a desire and longing to enter into the courts of the Lord
Mein Leib und Seele freuen sich in dem lebendigen GottMy heart and my flesh rejoice in the living God
Wohl denen, die in deinem Hause wohnenBlessed are they who dwell in thy house
Dir loben dich immerdarThey will be always praising thee

Text: From Psalm 84

Organ solo: Sonata No 3 in A , 1st movement | Felix Mendelssohn (1809-47)

Mendelssohn’s debt to JS Bach is evident in his own organ music. He was himself a fine organist, noted for his mastery of Bach’s works, and as an improviser. This sonata includes a Chorale prelude based on Luther’s hymn “Aus tiefer Not schrei ich zu dir” (From deep affliction I cry out to you).

Ave Maria | Simon Lindley (1948-2025)

Appropriately, we are performing the new commission Brides of Christ between two pieces of music focussed upon Mary, Mother of Jesus. This Ave Maria by the founder-director of St Peter’s Singers, Simon Lindley, has found a home in just about every parish and cathedral choir library in the land, on account of its beautiful tunefulness.

Ave Maria, gratia plena.Hail Mary, full of grace.
Dominus tecum.The Lord is with thee.
Benedicta tu in mulieribus,Blessed art thou among women,
et benedictus fructus ventris tuae, Jesu.and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Sancta Maria, Mater DeiHoly Mary, Mother of God
Ora pro nobis peccatoribusPray for us sinners
Nunc et in hora mortis nostrae.Now and at the hour of our death
AmenAmen

Brides of Christ (world premiere)| Fiona Pacey & Hannah Stone

This is the first ever performance of this new work, created by two of our members.

Fiona Pacey writes:

Imagine two nuns in a 16th century convent. What brought them here? What sort of life do they have? In this collaboration between poet Hannah Stone and composer Fiona Pacey, we overhear a conversation in which two of them talk about their experience and how they came to be there.

The vocal lines are semi-aleatoric; they sound spontaneous, just as a conversation would. In the background the choir provides episodes of busyness which resolve into unity, as a convent community might come together at the end of a day to sing the divine office.

My father said “Child, you must go
And live with these holy women;
At home are too many daughters
And not enough bread to go around”.

My Father called me, and I heard
The still small voice above the clamour
Of my home. Mother said “Wait!”
But I was sure of my calling .

I said goodbye to my sweetheart,
Wept for the babies I did not bear.

Jesus says “Here are your sisters;
Those who do the will of God.”

And here, there is food for the belly,
A clean shift, a place to lie down;
Now I have so many mothers!
(Some are stern and some are cheerful).

They tell me how Mary said “yes”
When God had work for her to do,
That she, another simple girl,
Found beauty in obedience.

I submit to no earthly spouse,
Rejoice to be a bride of Christ,
Wear the breastplate of righteousness
Instead of fine robes and jewels.
My faith is buckled for a belt;
The words of your gospels my pearls.

They teach me – how I like to learn –
The many skills they share with me!

The seed of silent contemplation
Swelled within me, mothered to life
By prayer; birthing peace and mercy.
I go to the inner room
Of my soul, and there I am heard.

And most of all I love to sing,
To blend my voice in Thanksgiving
For this little heaven on earth
And God’s great favour shown to me.

My spirit swims in the silence,
And, when we gather, sings in chords,
Sweet harmony in praise of God.

Text: Hannah Stone

Soloists: Hannah Stone & Claire White-McKay

Ave Maris Stella | Edvard Grieg (1843-1907)

Ave maris stella,
Dei Mater alma,
Atque semper virgo
Felix caeli porta
Hail bright star of heaven
Loving mother of God
And always a virgin
Happy gate of Heaven
Solve vincla reis:
Profer lumen caecis,
Mala nostra pelle
Bona cuncta posce
Break the chains of sinners
Bring light to the blind
Drive away our evils
Ask for all good
Vitam praesta puram
Iter para tutum
Ut, videntes Jesum,
Semper collaetemur
Keep life pure
Make the journey safe
So that, seeing Jesus
We may for ever rejoice together
Sit laus Deo Patri,
Summo Christo decus,
Spiritui Sancto;
Tribus honor unus, Amen
Praise be to God the Father,
Glory to Christ in the highest,
With the Holy Spirit
One honour to the three, Amen

Text: From a Hymn for Vespers from the 9th Century

Interval

My spirit sang all day | Gerald Finzi (1901-1956)

This ecstatic setting of Robert Bridges’ poem My Spirit sang all day is best explained perhaps by the key fact that the composer’s wife was called Joy!

My spirit sang all day
O my joy
Nothing my tongue could say,
Only My joy!

My heart an echo caught
O my joy
And spake, tell me thy thought,
Hide not thy joy.

My eyes gan peer around,
O my joy
What beauty hast thou found?
Shew us thy joy.

My jealous ears grew whist;
O my joy
Music from heaven is’t,
Sent for our joy?

She also came and heard;
O my joy,
What, said she, is this word?
What is thy joy?

And I replied,
O see, O my joy,
‘Tis thee, I cried, ’tis thee:
Thou art my joy.

Text: Robert Bridges (1844-1930)

The Blue Bird | Charles Villiers Stanford (1852-1924)

Charles Stanford’s motionless, almost hallucinatory setting of Mary Coleridge’s poem provides a complete contrast to the Finzi. It is one of the most popular secular choral pieces from the Edwardian period with its soaring soprano solo, and exquisite image of perfect beauty.

The lake lay blue below the hill.
O’er it, as I looked, there flew
Across the waters, cold and still,
A bird whose wings were palest blue.

The sky above was blue at last,
The sky beneath me blue in blue.
A moment, ere the bird had passed,
It caught his image as he flew.

Text: Mary E Coleridge (1861-1907)

Soloist: Debbie Trigg

The Turtle Dove | Ralph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)

Ralph Vaughan Williams is well known for collecting English folksongs in an attempt to preserve this important part of our culture. His gift for arranging them without losing their essential character is beautifully demonstrated by this charming love song.

Fare you well my dear I must be gone
and leave you for a while
If I roam away I’ll come back again
Though I roam ten thousand miles, my dear
Though I roam ten thousand miles

So fair though art my bonney lass
So deep in love as I
But I never will prove false to the bonney lass I love
Till the stars fall from the sky my dear
Till the stars fall from the sky

The sea will never run dry my dear
Nor the rocks never melt with the sun
But I never will prove false to the bonney lass I love
Till all these things be done my dear
Till all these things be done

O yonder doth sit that little turtle dove
He doth sit on yonder high tree
A making a moan for the loss of his love
As I will do for thee my dear
As I will do for thee

Text: Traditional

Soloist: David Hawkin

My love dwelt in a Northern land | Edward Elgar (1857-1934)

Edward Elgar’s emotive setting of Scottish poet Andrew Lang’s  Romance does full justice to the eerie, dream-like text, complete with the final twist. Listen out for how the staccato rhythms in the middle parts, set against the long tune sung by sopranos and tenors, create that strange, dream-like quality.

My love dwelt in a northern land
A dim tower in a forest green
Was his, and far away the sand,
And gray wash of the waves were seen,
The woven forest boughs between.

And through the northern summer night
The sunset slowly died away,
And herds of strange deer, silver white,
Came gleaming through the forest gray,
And fled like ghosts before the day.

And oft, that month, we watch’d the moon
Wax great and white o’er wood and lawn,
And wane, with waning of the June,
Till, like a brand for battle drawn,
She fell, and flamed in a wild dawn.

I know not if the forest green
Still girdles round that castle gray,
I know not if, the boughs between,
The white deer vanish ere the day.
The grass above my love is green,
His heart is colder than the clay.

Text: Andrew Lang (1844-1912)

Lay a garland | Robert Pearsall (1795-1856)

Robert de Pearsall’s mournful but lush 8-part setting of words by Beaumont and Fletcher titled Lay a Garland is the earliest of these part-songs. Enjoy the sumptuous harmonies!

Lay a garland on her hearse
Of the dismal yew
Maidens, willow branches bear
Say she died true
Her love was false, but she was firm
From her hour of birth;
Upon her buried body lie
Lightly, thou gentle earth.

Text: adapted by the composer from words by Beaumont and Fletcher

Organ solo: The Prayer | David Foster (arr Lee Ward)

Enjoy Lee’s arrangement of David Foster’s song, made famous by Celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli.

The Sound of Silence | Paul Simon (b 1941)

This classic needs no introduction!

Medley from West Side Story | Leonard Bernstein (1918-1990)

This medley of hit songs from Bernstein’s hit from the 1950s (words by Stephen Sondheim) provides some pizazz with which to finish.

Concert programme notes for My spirit sang all day (Sharow)

poster image for choral concert called My Spirit sang all day

Note: This is an annotated form of the programme notes for this recital, exploiting web technologies to allow readers to delve deeper into the biographies of the composers and the meaning of musical and religious terms as they wish.


My spirit sang all day

Choral songs of the world and the spirit

Programme

Please click on the composers’ names to find about more about them

Missa Aeterna Christi MuneraPierluigi da Palestrina (1525-94)
MiserereJames MacMillan (b 1959)
Dum transisset sabbatum
(second setting)
John Taverner (c1490-1545)
This joyful Eastertidearr. Charles Wood (1866-1926)

Interval

during which refreshments will be served

Lay a garlandRobert Pearsall (1795-1856)
The Blue BirdCharles Villiers Stanford (1852-1924)
The Turtle DoveRalph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)
Linden LeaRalph Vaughan Williams (1872-1958)
Lux AurumqueEric Whitacre (b 1970)
My love dwelt in a Northern LandEdward Elgar (1857-1934)
My spirit sang all dayGerald Finzi (1901-1956)
The long day closesArthur Sullivan (1842-1900)
My soul, there is a countryHubert Parry (1848-1918)

St Peter’s Singers

Alexander Woodrow


Texts and Translations

Missa Aeterna Christi Munera

The Latin text and an English Translation of the Mass can be accessed here.

Miserere

The Latin text and an English Translation of the Mass can be accessed here.

Dum transisset Sabbatum

Dum transisset sabbatumWhen the Sabbath was over
Maria Magdalene et Maria Jacobi et SalomeMary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and Salome
emerunt aromatabought aromatic oils
ut venientes ungerunt Jesum.intending to go and anoint Jesus.
AlleluiaAlleluia

Lux aurumque

LuxLight
Calida gravisque pura velut aurumWarm and heavy as pure gold
Et canunt angeli molliterAnd the angels sing softly
Modo natumTo the new-born baby
Translated by Charles Anthony SilvestriEnglish original poem by Edward Esch

Why is JS Bach’s Mass in B Minor so special ?

Photo of the first page of the manuscript of the B Minor Mass by JS Bach

There’s no doubt about it: Johann Sebastian Bach’s Mass in B Minor is a masterpiece. It is one of the most exhilarating and satisfying works both to perform and to listen to, and probably receives more performances now than at any time in its 275-year history.

We are thrilled to be performing it at Leeds Minster on Good Friday 18 April at 7pm. Tickets are available and you will be very welcome.

At St Peter’s Singers, we’ve been enjoying some wonderful rehearsals: those of us who know the work have loved returning to it afresh, discovering new things we hadn’t heard before; and those who don’t know it have been blown away by the beauty of the music as well as the technical demands it makes on us as singers.

The B Minor Mass is the product of a formidable intellect, a synthesis of Bach’s musical and theological knowledge, his spirituality and understanding of the human condition, and his artistic mastery. And despite its immense complexity, it remains accessible and deeply moving, resonating with audiences across centuries.

You only have to hear the first four spine-tingling bars, as they build to the most impassioned pleading from the human soul, to know that despite the Latin words and the unfamiliar text, this music can speak both to you and for you, whatever you do or don’t believe.

And with those four bars a journey begins, with music that gives voice to deep sadness and grief, wildly joyful dance and celebration, cheeky intimacy, solemn formality, prayerfulness, awe, longing, confidence, even doubt – an astonishing range of human feelings and experience. And all the while working through the Latin text of the Catholic Church’s Mass!

It’s extraordinary to think that Bach himself almost certainly never heard it in its entirety: he only completed it in the last year of his life, and almost certainly didn’t have the resources it requires at his disposal in Leipzig. Listening to it complete, as we do, is a privilege.

But it was composed long ago, and the world has changed, so what does it mean for us today, and does performing it on Good Friday mean anything?

The answer varies, of course, depending on your perspective.

For many, the music still speaks deeply on its own, with a spirituality that touches the parts that little else can reach. It provides a much needed stability and counterweight to the shallow and fly-by-night nature of our Social Media-driven world. The opacity of the Latin ensures that the text is not intrusive. Perhaps the Easter weekend, with its two bank holidays, may bring a slight jolt in the normal rhythms of life, and with it perhaps a prompt to seek out meaning and connection with something deeper than daily life normally offers. Perhaps a live performance in the grandeur of a beautiful church may prove more meaningful than a recording played in the living room.

For Christians, anything that illuminates faith and encourages prayer may be welcome. For those who, on Good Friday, may have experienced a week of intense and dramatic re-enactment of Jesus’ last days and hours, the evening – with Jesus now laid to rest in the tomb – brings a spiritual, almost eerie, peace, and the chance to step back and ponder what it all means. The Mass, reflecting as it does on the sacrifice made by Christ on the cross, is an ideal and – in translation – familiar text, and Bach’s music, as it explores and illuminates it almost clause by clause can undoubtedly bring insight, joy and prayerfulness.

But wherever we come from, Bach’s mighty Mass in B Minor can speak to us all. On the one hand it is steeped in his mature and very considerable understanding of the text, and yet on the other he presents to us the most opaque, mysterious words written in a rich but dead language. It is the music that speaks, conjuring up a sense of great spiritual mystery, meaning and prayerfulness, maybe drawing our tears of sorrow and voicing our pleas but above all calling us to the dance.

Further reading

Find out more about its history and meaning

Programme notes for the concert

What to expect at a St Peter’s Singers concert

More about the concert

Concert Programme notes for Mass in B Minor

Bach mass in B minor 2025 square 1 - Concert Programme notes for Mass in B Minor

Leeds Minster

Good Friday 18 April 7.00pm

Note: This is an annotated form of the programme notes for this recital, exploiting web technologies to allow readers to delve deeper into the biographies of the composers and the meaning of musical and religious terms as they wish.


Mass in B Minor

Johann Sebastian Bach

1685-1750

Ruby Hendrysoprano
Lucy Appleyardmezzo
Joanna Gamblecontralto
Toby Wardtenor
Quentin Brownbass-baritone

St Peter’s Singers

National Festival Orchestra

Sally Robinson leader

Shaun Turnbull continuo

Alexander Woodrow conductor

We would like to thank Canon Paul Maybury, Rector, and the Churchwardens of Leeds Minster for their significant support for St Peter’s Singers, and for hosting tonight’s event.

We would also like to thank The Friends of the Music of Leeds Minster for their generous support.


We remember tonight with the deepest affection and gratitude our Founder and former Director of Music

SL VQ - Concert Programme notes for Mass in B Minor
Photo by Nicki Roach

Dr Simon Lindley (1948-2025)

He was passionate about the music of JS Bach and conducted many inspired and memorable performances


Mass in B Minor

Missa

Kyrie eleisonchorus
Christe Eleisonsoprano I, soprano II duet
Kyrie eleisonchorus
Gloria in excelsis Deochorus
Et in terra paxchorus
Laudamus tesoprano II solo
Gratias agimus tibichorus
Domine Deussoprano I, tenor duet
Qui tollis peccata mundichorus
Qui sedes ad dextram patrisalto solo
Quoniam to solus sanctusbass solo
Cum sancto spirituchorus

Symbolum Nicenum (Credo)

Credo in unum Deumchorus
Patrem omnipotentemchorus
Et in unum Dominumsoprano I, alto duet
Et incarnatuschorus
Crucifixuschorus
Et resurrexitchorus
Et in spiritum sanctumbass solo
Confiteorchorus
Et expectochorus

Sanctus, Osanna, Benedictus and Agnus Dei

Sanctuschorus
Osannachorus
Benedictustenor solo
Agnus Deialto solo
Dona nobis pacemchorus

Text and Translation

The Latin text and an English Translation can be accessed here.


About the B Minor Mass

Bach only completed his ‘Great Catholic Mass’ late in his life, and remarkably, he almost certainly never heard it performed complete. Along with the Kunst der Fuge (‘Art of the Fugue’) on which he was also working in his final years, he seems to have thought of it as a final legacy, a statement both of his faith and of his mastery of Counterpoint. And yet it was not composed in a single act, and he may not have envisioned the whole work when he started on it. So how did this masterpiece come into being ?

Some background: Bach had arrived at Leipzig to his new post as Cantor at the churches of St Thomas and St Nicholas in 1723. He immediately set about re-invigorating the music and for the next five years composed at an astonishing rate: on average a 20-30 minute Cantata every week. In addition, 1724 saw the first performance of the St John Passion, and the St Matthew Passion was composed in 1727. By the last years of the decade he was effectively burned out, at odds with his employers, and settled at that point for using previous compositions to fulfil his church duties.

Composition and genesis

The creation of the B Minor Mass spans several decades but didn’t start in any formal sense until 1733, when he composed a Missa for the Elector of Saxony, which consists of the Kyrie and Gloria sections of the full Mass. He was hoping to secure the title of Court Composer.  An offer was eventually forthcoming, but not one that provided the hoped-for exit from Leipzig, and the score was left to gather dust. But this initial offering eventually blossomed into what we now recognize as the B Minor Mass, and actually comprised all the music that precedes tonight’s interval.

The Missa of 1733

The Missa which Bach presented to the Elector of Saxony in 1733 was crafted with meticulous care, showcasing Bach’s ability to intertwine complex Counterpoint with expressive melody, as well as florid duets in the Neapolitan operatic style then in vogue at the Dresden court.

Some of the movements drew on music he had written a long time previously, which he adapted and, as was his custom, took great care to improve. Much of it was composed while he was at Dresden in the spring of 1733, and it was almost certainly performed in the July of that year, but whether Bach directed the performance we don’t know.

With extended fugues and complex choral Counterpoint, ecstatic dances, operatic duets and moments of tender introspection, all underpinned by the considerable resources of the Dresden Court orchestra (three high trumpets, two bassoons et al), it was on a scale never seen before.

This Missa set the standard for the subsequent movements, which Bach would add some fifteen or so years later.

Expansion and completion

It wasn’t until sometime around 1747 that Bach decided to expand the 1733 Missa into a full Mass. Driven perhaps by personal reflection in his later years, Bach embarked on the ambitious task of composing the remaining sections: the Credo, Sanctus, Benedictus, and Agnus Dei. He prepared for this by a thorough study of stile antico (a term meaning ‘ancient style’) exemplified in Mass settings by the likes of Palestrina, Caldara and Lotti.

The Credo (or ‘Symbolum Nicenum’) was conceived on a scale to match the Gloria, making it too long for use in a Church Service (although this has happened!).

Much of it was composed from scratch to fit a carefully designed structural scheme which placed at its centre the three narrative movements recounting the bare facts of Christ’s birth, death and resurrection (Et incarnatus, Crucifixus, Et resurrexit) on which the Christian faith is founded. Of these the Et incarnatus, composed late in 1749 in a late change of plan, is probably the last complete piece of music he wrote, while the Crucifixus, which follows seamlessly on, was originally composed with German words for a Cantata as far back as 1714. The structural change created by the insertion of the Et incarnatus, ensured that in line with Lutheran theology of the Cross, the Crucifixus became the central piece in the structure of the Credo.

It seems that the Symbolum Nicenum left a particularly strong impression on the next generation, with his son Emmanuel, now in Hamburg, composing a Magnificat in 1749 that was clearly indebted to his father’s latest work.

The remaining movements (Sanctus, Benedictus, Agnus Dei) were partially assembled from earlier compositions (the six-part Sanctus from 1724, the Agnus Dei (whose origins lay in the Ascension Oratorio BWV 11 or even earlier), and the Dona nobis pacem (which like the Gratias movement in the Gloria repeats music from the 1731 Cantata BWV 29), while the eight-part Osanna and the Benedictus were fresh compositions.

It is extraordinary, but perhaps the hallmark of Bach’s genius, that despite the diversity of styles and forms, the long gestation, and the re-use of earlier material, the B Minor Mass is imbued with a deep sense of coherence, unity and purpose, allowing it to resonate on multiple levels. This may be partially explained by Bach’s incredibly careful planning of the work’s structure, but also by recurring use of themes, motifs and symbolic musical gestures, such as the cross-motif and the use of numerology, even his B-A-C-H signature (German notation for B flat, A , C, B natural – but inverted on this occasion).

Impact and legacy

Since its completion, the B Minor Mass has been celebrated as one of the pinnacles of Western music. Although it was never performed in its entirety during Bach’s lifetime, its significance has only grown with time. His sons performed sections of it, and allowed copies to be made, one of which, remarkably, came into the hands of Samuel Wesley, father of Samuel Sebastian (who was the first organist of this church). So the work never quite fell into the obscurity that befell the St Matthew Passion for a century. Musicians and scholars alike have marvelled ever since at its complexity, beauty, and spiritual depth.

What is the meaning of the Mass in B Minor?

This question is essentially impossible to answer, such is the richness of the music within which Bach wraps the text.

But perhaps the place to start is with the Catholic Mass, which is the primary form of worship in the Catholic Christian Church (including much of the Anglican church, even if it prefers the term ‘Eucharist’). In this service of thanksgiving, the Church remembers and gives thanks for Christ’s sacrificial act of Love in his death by crucifixion on the Cross, through which fallible humankind is reconciled to God. The service re-enacts the Last Supper that Jesus shared with his disciples, and goes right back to the earliest days of the Church’s existence. As such it combines ritual, re-enactment and prayer.

It follows a basic pattern that includes an act of penitence and forgiveness as preparation (including the Kyrie), then an expression of praise and worship (Gloria), reading of Scripture and teaching, an assertion of Christian beliefs (Credo), prayers for those in need, and then the great thanksgiving and sharing of the bread and wine in memory of the Last Supper (incorporating the Sanctus, Benedictus and Agnus Dei).

The words usually set to music for the Western Catholic Mass, as here in the Mass in B Minor, consist of what is known as the ‘Ordinarium’ – the texts in the service that never vary from week to week:

Kyrie eleison A plea for mercy, expressed in Greek.
GloriaAn extended expression of praise and worship of the Godhead
CredoA sequence of statements beginning I believe… which lay out the central tenets of the Christian faith, as determined at the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD.
Note: this was a bit like the final communique from a modern G7 or COP summit, with every clause having been fought over, hence some of the rather strange formulations designed to hold the line against popular heresies (false doctrines). It expresses the core teaching of the Christian faith as it had developed over the three hundred or so years since Christ’s death.
Sanctus & BenedictusThe Sanctus, which quotes Isaiah’s Vision of the Lord , comes early in the Great Prayer of Thanksgiving where those on earth join the heavenly hosts in praise of God. The Benedictus expresses a blessing on Christ.
Agnus DeiA prayer to Jesus, the sacrificial Lamb of God, to have mercy and grant us peace.

On the one hand these texts have to be seen as part of an extremely rich ritual whose significance is appreciated more fully with repetition and practise. It should not be forgotten that for millions of Christians over the ages this ritual was conducted in Latin, an opaque and ancient language whose words they may have learnt by rote, but of which they may have had little understanding. So in some senses it was the ritual that was important, not the precise meaning of the words. As such, this means that with musical settings such as the Mass in B Minor, understanding the words is not necessarily essential and the music may convey meaning in its own right.

But on the other hand, it is impossible, especially with the Mass in B Minor, to ignore Bach’s response to the meaning of the words. To take a few examples: the prayerful upward inflections and downward sighs in the first Kyrie Fugue, the festive joy of the opening of the Gloria, the sense of mystery in Qui tollis and Et incarnatus, the unbridled liberation at the first mention of the Holy Spirit in Cum sancto spiritu, the extraordinary sinking feeling as Jesus’ burial is recorded at the end of the Crucifixus, the chatty intimacy of the Soprano and Tenor soloists as God the Son comes into the picture in Domine Deus, the initial hesitation when the words et expecto are first introduced (‘I look for the resurrection of the dead’) at the end of the Confiteor, and so many more. All these reflect a profound understanding of the theology, and express it in human terms, the musical language of human emotions, thereby repaying the listener’s engagement with a text that may otherwise be opaque and unapproachable.

For Christians, Good Friday is the culmination of a week in which re-enactment of Jesus’ last days and hours is often the primary means for trying to enter into and discover the meaning of those events. But by the evening of Good Friday, with Jesus dead and his body laid to rest, the opportunity arises to step back and reflect on what it all means. There could hardly be a better opportunity for this than that provided by Bach’s Mass in B Minor.

These notes owe a substantial debt to John Eliot Gardiner’s superlative book on Bach: Music in the Castle of Heaven. If any of the above has aroused your interest, you would doubtless be richly rewarded by giving it some time.

Recital Programme Notes for ‘Visions of Darkness and Light’

A poster image advertising St Peter's Singers recital at Leeds Cathedral on 17 Feb 2025

Leeds Cathedral

Monday 17 February 1.15pm

Free admission

Note: This is an annotated form of the programme notes for this recital, exploiting web technologies to allow readers to delve deeper into the biographies of the composers and the meaning of musical and religious terms as they wish.

Programme

Vast Ocean of LightJonathan Dove (b 1959)
A Taylor TrilogySimon Lindley (b 1948)
MiserereJames MacMillan (b 1959)
Messe SolennelleJean Langlais (1907-1991)

Dr Lindley’s work A Taylor Trilogy was commissioned by St Peter’s Singers of Leeds in grateful recognition of the composer’s generous and inspirational leadership, 1977-2021, and here receives its first performance.

*****

St Peter’s Singers

Darius Battiwalla organ

Alexander Woodrow director

Vast Ocean of Light                                

Jonathan Dove (b 1959)

Vast Ocean of light, whose rayes surround
The Universe, who know’st nor ebb, nor shore,
Who lend’st the Sun his sparkling drop, to store
With overflowing beams Heav’n, ayer, ground,
Whose depths beneath the Centre none can sound,
Whose heights ‘bove heav’n, and thoughts so lofty soar,
Whose breadth no feet, no lines, no chains, no eyes survey,
Whose length no thoughts can reach, no worlds can bound,
What cloud can mask thy face? where can thy ray
Find an Eclipse? what night can hide Eternal Day?

Phineas Fletcher (1582-1650)

Jonathan Dove (b. 1959) is a versatile composer in a host of genres, and studied composition with Robin Holloway at Cambridge University. Vast Ocean of Light (2010) sets poetry by Phineas Fletcher, metaphysical English poet of the Renaissance. Dove has said, ‘Light […] has always been a source of inspiration to me, and the heavenly bodies often provoke a desire to create some kind of numinous music’. Listen out for the ostinato sparkling quavers of the organ accompaniment, the dazzling harmonies, the striking use of Canon between the voices, and the overall sense of spaciousness and awe which the music evokes.

A Taylor Trilogy                                          

Simon Lindley (b 1948)

I                                                                                               from ‘Easter Day’ in The Golden Grove

What glorious light!
How bright a Sun after so sad a night
Does now begin to dawn!
O dearest God preserve our souls
In holy innocence;
Or if we do amiss,
Make us to rise again to th’life of Grace,
That we may live with thee, and see thy glorious face,
The crown of holy Penitence.
Allelujah.


II                                                                                            
from ‘Pentecost’ in The Golden Grove

Lord, let the flames of holy charity,
And all her gifts and graces slide
Into our hearts, and there abide;
That thus refined, we may soar above
With it unto the element of love,
Even unto Thee, dear Spirit,
And there eternal peace and rest inherit.
Amen.

III                                                        from ‘A Hymn upon St John’s Day’ in The Golden Grove

Let’s sing Him up agen !
Each man winde up’s heart
To bear a part
In that angelick quire, and show
His glory high as He was low !
Let’s sing t’wards men good will and charity,
Peace upon Earth, glory to God on high
Hallelujah, Hallelujah !
Mysterious God, regard me when I pray:
And when this load of clay
Shall fall away,
O let Thy gracious hand conduct me up,
Where on the Lamb’s rich viands I may sup:
And in this last Supper I
May with Thy friend in Thy sweet bosome lie
For ever in Eternity.
Allelujah.

Jeremy Taylor (1613-1667)

Commissioned by St Peter’s Singers, Simon Lindley’s A Taylor Trilogy is a caring yet confident setting of extracts from the writings of Jeremy Taylor, Bishop of Down and Connor. Taylor is arguably under-represented in the choral repertoire, and so this composer’s very personal selection is most welcome. The sensitive choral writing ebbs and flows unhindered by gratuity and in so doing allows the text to thrive by its own great merit.

Miserere                                                          

James MacMillan (b 1959)

for the King James translation click here


Miserere mei, Deus, secundum magnam misericordiam tuam:
et secundum multitudinem miserationum tuarum, dele iniquitatem mean

Amplius lava me ab iniquitate mea: et a peccato meo munda me

Quoniam iniquitatem meam ego cognosco: et peccatum meum contra me est semper

Tibi soli peccavi et malum, coram te feci: ut justificeris in sermonibus tuis, et vincas cum judicaris


Ecce enim in iniquitatibus conceptus sum: et in peccatis concepit me mater mea

Ecce enim veritatem dilexisti: incerta et occula sapientiae tuae manifestasti mihi

Asperges me hyssopo, et mundabor: lavabis me, et super nivem de albabor

Auditui meo dabis gaudium et laetitiam: et exsultabunt ossa humiliata

Averte faciem tuam a peccatis meis: et omnes iniquitates meas dele

Cor mundum crea in me, Deus: et spiritum rectum innova in visceribus meis

Ne projicias me a facie tua: et spiritum sanctum tuum ne auferas a me  

Redde mihi laetitiam salutaris tui: et spiritu principali confirma me

Docebo iniquos vias tuas: et impii ad te convertentur

Libera me de sanguinibus, Deus, Deus salutis meae: et exsultabit lingua mea justitiam tuam

Domine, labia mea aperies: et os meum annuntiabit laudem tuam

Quoniam si voluisses sacrificium, dedissem utique : holocaustis non dedectaberis

Sacrificium Deo spiritus contribulatus: cor contritum et humiliatum, Deus, non despicies

Benigne fac, Domine, in bona voluntate tua Sion: ut ædificentur muri Jerusalem

Tunc acceptabis sacrificium justitiae, oblationes et holocausta: tunc imponent super altare tuum vitulos

Have mercy on me, O God, in your goodness:
in your great tenderness wipe away my faults;

Wash me clean of my guilt:   and purify me from my sin

For I am well aware of my faults:   my sin is constantly in mind

Against you, you alone, I have sinned, I have done what you see to be wrong: that you may be justified in your words, and victorious when you give judgement

You know I was born sinful:   a sinner from the moment of conception

But you delight in sincerity of heart: and in secret you teach me wisdom

Purify me with hyssop until I am clean:   wash me until I am whiter than snow

Let me hear the sound of joy and gladness: and the bones you have crushed will dance

Turn your face away from my sins:   and wipe away all my guilt

Create a clean heart in me, O God: and renew a resolute spirit within me

Do not banish me from your presence: do not take away your holy spirit from me

Give me back the joy of your salvation:   keep my spirit steady and willing:

I shall teach transgressors your way: and the sinners will return to you

Deliver me from bloodshed, O God,  God my saviour: and my tongue will acclaim your righteousness;

Lord, open my lips: and my mouth will speak out your praise

Sacrifice gives you no pleasure, or I would offer it: but you do not desire burnt offerings  
Sacrifice to God is this broken spirit:   you will not scorn this crushed and broken heart, O God

In your graciousness do good to Zion:   rebuild the walls of Jerusalem

Then there will be proper sacrifice to please you – holocaust and whole oblation: then shall young bulls to be offered on your altar

Psalm 51

Sir James MacMillan (b. 1959) studied composition with Wakefield-born Kenneth Leighton and John Casken, his music being inspired by many things, including his Catholic faith and the folk music of his native Scotland. Miserere Mei is a substantial ‘a cappella’ work, setting verses from Psalm 51 (as Allegri famously did centuries earlier), and placing significant technical and expressive demands upon the choir. The music has a small number of principal musical themes that occur in various guises throughout the work. There is some amazingly virtuosic soprano writing early on, and a number of very powerful and dramatic moments, a superbly affecting section of simple homophonic free chant at the centre, and at the end a great sense of peace and tranquillity when the writing gives way to a beautiful E major hushed cadence.

Messe Solennelle                                     

Jean Langlais (1907-1991)

Kyrie  
Kyrie eleison
Christe eleison
Kyrie eleison  

Gloria in excelsis  
Gloria in excelsis Deo,
et in terra pax hominibus bonæ voluntatis.
Laudamus te.
Benedicimus te.
Adoramus te.
Glorificamus te.
Gratias agimus tibi
propter magnam gloriam tuam.
Domine Deus, Rex cælestis,
Deus Pater omnipotens.
Domine Fili unigenite, Jesu Christe.
Domine Deus,
Agnus Dei,
Filius Patris.
Qui tollis peccata mundi,
miserere nobis.
Qui tollis peccata mundi,
suscipe deprecationem nostram.
Qui sedes ad dexteram Patris,
miserere nobis.
Quoniam tu solus Sanctus.
Tu solus Dominus.
Tu solus Altissimus,
Jesu Christe.
Cum Sancto Spiritu,
in gloria Dei Patris.
Amen.  

Sanctus  
Sanctus, Sanctus, Sanctus,
Dominus Deus Sabaoth.
Pleni sunt cæli et terra gloria tua.  
Hosanna in excelsis.  

Benedictus  
Benedíctus qui venit
in nomine Domini.
Hosanna in excelsis  

Agnus Dei  
Agnus Dei,
qui tollis peccata mundi
miserere nobis
Agnus Dei,
qui tollis peccata mundi
miserere nobis
Agnus Dei,
qui tollis peccata mundi
dona nobis pacem

Lord, have mercy upon us
Christ, have mercy upon us
Lord, have mercy upon us      


Glory be to God on high,
and in earth peace, good will towards men.
We praise you.
We bless you.
We worship you.
We glorify you.
We give thanks to thee
For your great glory.
O Lord God, Heavenly King,
God the Father Almighty.
O Lord, the only-begotten Son, Jesu Christ;
O Lord God,
Lamb of God,
Son of the Father.
Who takes away the sins of the world,
have mercy upon us.
You who takes away the sins of the world, receive our prayer.
You who sits at the right hand of the Father,
have mercy upon us.
For you only are holy.
You only are the Lord.
You only are most high,
Jesus Christ,
With the Holy Spirit,
In the glory of God the Father.
Amen.      


Holy, holy, holy
Lord Lord God of power and might,
Heaven and earth are full of your glory. Hosanna in the highest.      


Blessed is he who comes
in the name of the Lord.
Hosanna in the highest.      


Lamb of God,
who takes away the sins of the world,
have mercy upon us
Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world,
have mercy upon us
Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world,
grant us your peace

Roman Missal

Jean Langlais (1907-1991) was a famous, blind Parisian-based organist, composer and teacher. A pupil of Marcel Dupré and Paul Dukas, he held the position of organist at the Basilica of Sainte-Clotilde in Paris for some 43 years. The Messe Solennelle (1949) is written for choir and two organs, one exceedingly powerful and set at the West End of the church (the Grand Orgue) and one much more accompanimental in nature (the Petit Orgue). As titular organist, Langlais would have played the Grand Orgue and his assistant organist the Petit Orgue; this afternoon, however, Darius manages to blend both organ parts seamlessly into one, making the most of the distinction between the thrilling ‘tutti’ sound of the Leeds cathedral organ for the tutti moments, juxtaposing with the softer stops for supporting the choir.

The five movements comprise some thrilling music. The influence of plainchant, and indeed organum (parallel harmony, Medieval in feel) is never far away, but with a thrilling 20th century use of harmony (in common with the wonderful Requiem by Duruflé, contemporary of Langlais, that was written just a few years earlier). Always attentive to the text that is set, Langlais’ setting of the Mass alternates skilfully between ethereal and tender; and ecstatic and thrilling, using a very distinctive and utterly ‘French’ tonal palette.

‘Period instruments’ and ‘historically-informed performance’ – a brief explainer

Stainer - 'Period instruments' and 'historically-informed performance' -  a brief explainer

A violin by Jacob Steiner, 1658

As in any walk of life, the technology of musical instruments has evolved with time, composers have exploited the new capabilities, techniques have evolved, and so sounds have changed and grown, pitch has risen, and musical styles, performance and taste have changed. And of course, older techniques and sounds have been lost and forgotten.

In our upcoming concert Baroque classics on June 29 we are collaborating, for the first time, with an ensemble that uses Period instruments and uses techniques and playing styles informed by historical research: Manchester Baroque.

So what is all the fuss about ? Here’s a brief explainer.

What are ‘Period instruments’ ?

Period instruments are musical instruments that date from about the time of the music that is being played and are set up in the way scholars think would have been the case at that time. For instruments from the Baroque period (1600-1750) this includes playing at a slightly lower pitch than is standard today.

String instruments such as violins are setup with gut strings rather than the modern ones that are wound in metal, and are bowed with bows of a different shape and tension from modern bows. The result is usually that the sound they make is softer, both in volume and timbre.

The difference in the bows forces the players to rethink how they use the bows to create musical phrases, usually resulting in shorter phrases and a greater degree of articulation, which both serve to make the music more interesting.

Wind instruments, particularly woodwind (oboes, bassoons and flutes) also tend to be softer, with the flutes made of wood, while brass instruments, being made without modern techniques that favour blend and uniformity, and in some cases without modern valve systems, are sometimes more characterful and quirky in their sound – as well as being harder to play.

This all allows some sounds and parts of the musical texture to be heard in a way that isn’t possible with modern instruments, leading a number of conductors and groups specialising in music from periods such as the Baroque period to to discover how the music would have sounded to the composers who wrote it and in particular what the composer’s intentions may have been.

Further reading:

Baroque violin

How I play both Baroque and modern violin

What is ‘historically-informed performance’?

‘Historically-informed performance’ is a term that is used to describe musical performance which combines the use of period instruments with technical and stylistic knowledge gleaned from academic research to produce musical performances that are as close to the intention and maybe the experience of the composer as we can make them.

The quest for historically-informed performance began in the later years of the twentieth century, being initially termed ‘authentic’ performance. However, as the quest developed and matured, its practitioners became more aware of the impossibility of genuinely authentic performance practice and adopted the term ‘historically-informed’ instead.

Historical information about musical performance is obtained by scrutinising original manuscripts, period instruments, treatises on style and technique, images, reports of concerts and any other available resource. It is then tested and validated in practice to determine what seems to work musically and physically.

So for example the precise way to execute the various types of ornament (extra decorative notes implied by a single musical symbol) in a particular region and period may be informed by a relevant document.

On the other hand, agreement that most Baroque music was played about a semitone lower (A=415Hz) than today’s standard concert pitch (A=440Hz) is based mainly on the physics of period instruments and the ease or otherwise with which vocal music by the likes of Bach and Handel fit the human voice.

It is of course impossible to really know exactly how music of times past would have sounded, and it is important to be clear that much historically-informed performance has also been shaped by experimentation, judgment and preference of experienced musicians, and to a degree, audiences.

The thrilling sounds of the modern professional Monteverdi Choir for instance, even with the elimination of vocal vibrato, are unlikely to be true to the sounds that would have been made by the relatively undernourished children and teenagers of Bach’s choirs in Leipzig, let alone the much smaller vocal ensembles that probably delivered the first performances of his St John and St Matthew Passions.

To an extent, this is a compromise required by modern concert hall performances, but also by taste, with the historically-informed styling combined with the sounds of the period instruments delivering truly thrilling music-making for the modern ear, and which the composers may have dreamt of, but possibly not really experienced.

Bach’s St John Passion

Johannespassion - Bach's St John Passion

A preview

As our Good Friday presentation of Bach’s magnificent St John Passion on Friday 29 March draws near, this offers a little by way of background about the work and its creation, as well as something about what you can expect if you come to hear it.

Background

The tradition of reciting the Gospel story of Christ’s last hours and death as part of Christian worship during Passiontide goes back many centuries. Spoken or sung to simple plainchant, the words of the characters would be voiced by different readers and the congregation would take the role of the crowd.

Apart from maybe the addition of a Chorale (or hymn), this had changed very little in the Lutheran Church until just a few years before Bach wrote the St John Passion in 1724.

This began to change in 1712, in Hamburg, when Heinrich Brockes produced a poetic text which paraphrased some parts of the biblical text, and added in a number of reflective if rather mawkish texts. Telemann and Handel were among those who, controversially, wrote elaborate, expressive music for Brockes’ text in a trend whose popularity eventually reached Telemann’s former stamping ground, the Neukirche in Leipzig.

Here, finally responding to loss of congregations, the more traditional regimes at the Thomaskirche and Nicolaikirche only relented and allowed more elaborate music just three years before Bach arrived as their Kantor in May 1723. The St John Passion was composed less than a year later, and, typically for Bach, elevated the trend to new heights.

Why is Bach’s St John Passion so special?

Firstly, Bach returned to the scriptural texts and then selected, altered and replaced Brockes’ poetic texts to bring a more serious theological tone to the work.

Secondly, he composed music of a sustained dramatic intensity never heard before outside the opera house.

Thirdly, through his command of highly chromatic harmonies he was able to transform what had become somewhat cliched musical tropes of the Baroque era into music that even now reaches far deeper and more authentically into the human psyche.

While shocking to some as it was, this should not have come as a surprise, as it represented the continuation of a clear and evolving intent on Bach’s part, shown in his weekly cantatas, to offer a blend of word and music that could engage both the intellect and the emotions of the faithful and so assist them in their devotions.

Engagement with the Gospel

In his magisterial study of Bach, Music in the Castle of Heaven, John Eliot Gardiner writes with great insight about Bach’s grasp and musical depiction of the main theological themes of St John’s Gospel, which are deeply embedded within the structures of the music. For instance, the Gospel dwells extensively on the paradox at the heart of the doctrine of the Incarnation, that Jesus could be both God and human being, humbled from his high heavenly throne to come down as man, and then be raised on high again but only through the most degrading death imaginable, raised on the Cross. Note the use of a vertical dimension in the language.

Bach depicts this graphically in the open chorus: the orchestra sets a scene of foreboding with low rumbling strings suggesting foreboding and tension, while two oboes keen out in the minor key a lament full of weeping suspensions over the top. Yet when the choir comes in, it is with a confident and declamatory high-pitched major-key chord on the German word for ‘Lord’ (‘Hail’ in our translation) and a song of praise, and then a quieter descending section to depict Christ’s humbling. Bach clearly understood and could express St John’s intentions. This was absolutely ground-breaking and is partly why he remains one of the greatest composers of sacred music that ever lived.

What is the St John Passion ? Is it an opera?

No, it’s not an opera – that would have been completely unacceptable in church in those days. But it is a highly charged and dramatised account of the trials and other events that preceded and ended with Jesus’ death. The St John Passion alternates between sections of the drama and periods of reflection, with choir and soloists switching between their dramatic roles in Jesus’ downfall, and then voicing the feelings and thoughts of the repentant Christian church and its members, allowing the listeners to meditate.

The drama is told in music that is astonishing in its power to depict but also to trigger emotions. Listen out in the scene about Peter for the cock crow on the cello, for how cold it was, and for the distress in Peter’s weeping. Listen too, in part two, for the brutality of Jesus’ scourging, and for the rising levels of tension, threat, and intimidation as the mob sets about Pilate.

Reflection and meditation come in two forms: the arias sung by soloists, and the chorales. Note how each aria, so carefully placed in the narrative, helps the listener respond and leads them on emotionally to the next stage in the story, whether it be theological meditation, a call to action, or just the expression of raw emotion.

Note too how Bach uses three arias after the death of Christ to pilot his listeners back down emotionally, first through theological reassurance then pure sadness to the elegiac dance of the final Chorus – Sleep well.

The chorales – hymns which would have been well-known and sung by the whole congregation – are contemplative and mostly restful. They must have given the congregation a brief moment to find their bearings amongst all the new musical ideas assailing them. But only to a degree – Bach had completely transformed the old tunes with his ground-breaking harmonisations. Singing them must have felt so different!

How have people reacted to the St John Passion ?

The reaction to the first performance was mixed to say the least, particularly from the authorities, and Bach was forced to make a number of revisions the following year, returning to the original version only, but significantly, in the last two years of his life.

The St John Passion has been quite slow to emerge from the shadow of the monumental St Matthew Passion, taking a while for twentieth-century period-specialist performers to peel away the layers of inappropriate performance practice and so reveal the full extent of Bach’s  thought, insight and ambition in planning its structure.

But it is now acknowledged as a masterpiece, and it gives us huge pride and joy to bring it to you.

With thanks and due acknowledgement to Sir John Eliot Gardiner for an inspiring read in his portrait of JS Bach Music in the castle of Heaven, on which this article extensively relies.

Double Entendre!

Double entendre socmed final A - Double Entendre!

Double Entendre! Yes, we’re teaming up with the Leeds Guild Of Singers so you can hear two choirs for the price of one!

The idea, which has been on the table for quite a while due to the pandemic, is not to form an augmented chorus for some performance on a grand scale, but to offer a programme of music written for single choir, double choir and a number of variations in between. So you can experience the thrill of hearing all 70 voices singing together but also enjoy the contrasts of each choir singing on their own.

Double choir ? it’s not a new idea

The idea of two groups of singers singing to each other in dialogue is nearly as old as western music itself. It goes back to the practice of monastic communities, who would sit facing each other in a collegiate arrangement, and chant alternate verses of the Psalms to each other, thus originating what is known as antiphonal music. Even in plainsong it works like a conversation with a musical idea stated in the first half of the verse and the answer contained in the response.

Antiphonal writing is a feature of the early choral writing of the Venetian Giovanni Gabrieli (b c1554) and also of Heinrich Schütz (b 1585) and indeed continues to be used through to modern times – those who attended our concert in November (A Vision of Albion) may recall Stanford’s brilliant motet Coelos ascendit hodie especially for its antiphonal writing.

Some composers have of course taken advantage of having choirs capable of singing in eight or more parts (two each of soprano, alto, tenor and bass) to create richer, symphonic textures with more colourful and complex harmonies. Parry’s There is an old belief, and indeed Vaughan Williams’ Mass in G Minor from that same concert are fine examples, with Vaughan Williams mixing antiphonal writing into it as well, and there are many more.

Programme

The programme for this concert includes a broad range of choral music ranging from the early German music of Schütz and Buxtehude through Romantic works by Mendelssohn, Rheinberger and Rachmaninoff to more modern works by Schnittke and Arvo Pärt. It illustrates the amazing creativity of these composers as they continually sought and found news ways to vary and develop the use of double choir resources.

The motet Jauchzet dem Herrn by Heinrich Schütz (himself influenced by Gabrieli) shows antiphonal writing at its strongest with echo effects and great rhythmic drive as two four-part choirs of sopranos, altos, tenors and basses fling words and musical ideas back and forth between them, almost interrupting each other at times. By contrast, the Magnificat that was once attributed to Buxtehude finds a different way of varying the sounds and textures by switching from 5-part choral writing to solo voices or single-voice ensembles. And in his lyrical motet Denn er hat seinen Engeln befohlen, Mendelssohn provides a further variation, creating separate groups out of the upper and lower voices for antiphonal use.

Rachmaninoff’s Choral Concerto and Schnittke’s Three Sacred Hymns take us into Russian Orthodox tradition, where the desire to enrich the music of the liturgy while retaining the restriction to just a cappella choral resources led to the development of great dynamism and richness, exemplified in the Choral Concerto. Schnittke demonstrates both antiphonal writing and the concerted building of richer choral sound, with the two being combined in the third hymn. Arvo Pärt, by contrast, and possibly seeking to return to basics, achieves the opposite in his setting of the Magnificat: a spare, minimalist, almost glacial texture created through, not despite, a multiplicity of parts, and a reminder of the simple chant that lies deep in the heart of all liturgical music.

The concert reaches its climax with the opulent Mass in E flat (‘Cantus Missae’) by Joseph Rheinberger. This magnificent work boasts antiphonal writing reflecting all the glory of the Venetian tradition, while also displaying mastery of contrapuntal textures – the weaving together of many moving parts – bequeathed to him in the German tradition by Bach and Mendelssohn. With all 70 or so voices of the two choirs combined in the warm key of E flat major, this work will provide an uplifting end to the concert and a fine memory to take away.

Three sacred hymnsAlfred Schnittke
Denn er hat seinen Engeln befohlenFelix Mendelssohn
Jauchzet dem HerrnHeinrich Schütz
MagnificatDieterich Buxtehude
MagnificatArvo Pärt
Choral ConcertoSergei Rachmaninoff
Mass in E flat ‘Cantus Missae’Joseph Rheinberger

Venue

The concert takes place in the beautiful setting of Leeds Minster at 4pm on Saturday 11 February, and will last about an hour. Refreshments will be served.

Leeds Minster is a large and well-ventilated building offering plenty of space, as well as impressive architecture and ambience. Car parking is available on streets nearby, in the car park by the Palace Hotel, and in the NCP Markets Car Park.

Music for Good Friday 2022

Italian Music for Passiontide

Dolorosa socmed 1024x768 - Music for Good Friday 2022

We look forward with great excitement to our presentation of Music for Good Friday, always one of the high points of our calendar, and one we’ve had to forgo for the last two years.

This year we present a programme of absolutely gorgeous music for Passiontide by Italian composers. Gregorio Allegri’s famous Miserere is included, as well as Antonio Lotti’s well-known Crucifixus est pro nobis in 8 parts.

But the real stars of this programme are settings of the Miserere (Psalm 51) and the 13th century latin poem Stabat Mater Dolorosa by Francesco and Domenico Scarlatti respectively. They were uncle and nephew, Francesco being the younger brother of the more famous Alessandro, who was Domenico’s father. They lived at the height of the Baroque period, Domenico being born in 1685, the same year as Handel and JS Bach.

Both these works will sound familiar to lovers of Vivaldi’s Gloria, but with different textures providing additional variety to the ear. Francesco’s Miserere exploits different combinations of soloists, expertly sung by members of the choir, mixed in between full choral movements.

220px Retrato de Domenico Scarlatti - Music for Good Friday 2022

Domenico writes for 10 vocal parts and continuo, demanding considerable virtuosity at times, but achieving a richness and sonority rarely matched in the Baroque era.

He rises superbly to the challenge of setting words that express so eloquently not just the sorrow of Jesus’ mother Mary as she watches her son dying a cruel death, but also the sorrow of any other compassionate human being reflecting on such events. As so often, the music reaches into places that the words, especially the latin ones, don’t necessarily reach.

They are very fine works, deserving of greater exposure. This is a rare chance to hear them live.

The music starts at 7.00pm on Good Friday 15 April 2022 in Leeds Minster, and will last about 75 minutes.

Why not book now ?